Found this at my IT job on a desk.
PDF of the graphic posted by OP (contains a few different versions)
Just posted these in case anyone was having trouble reading the photo, though it was taken very well.
The gender unicorn is a similar model that leaves room for gender identities entirely outside of the binary (albeit still simplistically)
Cool! It was printed out by one of the staff on that campus, glad someone found the source :)
itspronouncedmetrosexual (aka Sam Killerman) is a cishet white man who’s made a career out of speaking over marginalized voices.
He did not create the genderbread person but he chose to slap his name on it anyways.
He also tried to popularize the term trans* despite not being trans himself nor having the approval of actual trans people. (Trans* is a useless term since trans already includes all trans people. Trans* causes people to falsely think that trans is an uninclusive term)
Here’s a tumblr post for the plagiarism claim You can also find stuff by just searching for “sam killerman controversy” or similar. The other stuff you can find on his own website.
Edit: It seems like my Lemmy client is confusing Tumblr links for Lemmy instance links so I’ll just post it again below just in case.
https://whatdoesenbymean.tumblr.com/post/62247473507/itspronouncedmetrosexual-com-plagarised-the
Yeah this is by far my favourite version and the one I saw most recently while attending a queer group:
I have no idea who this guy is, but based on my own memories I’m pretty sure trans* did come from within the community. I know trans* as a term dates back at least to the early 00s because I remember seeing it around then, and from what I recall it wasn’t a new term, but one that came from 90s trans user groups (with the * being a programming reference to wildcards, because some things about trans spaces never change). Trans* was used to be inclusive of transgender and transsexual, which were common self identification terms at the time that obviously gave way to transgender.
But what we lost in the (pardon the pun) transition is that transgender as a term used to include many people who would consider themselves cisgender today. If you look through flyers and media from the time you’ll sometimes see illustrations of the ‘transgender umbrella,’ and it includes butch women, feminine men, drag performers, basically anyone who could conceivably fall into the ‘gender criminal’ category. What trans* did is give people a way to make it clear they were talking about both groups. And I think the inclusion of people we would now consider cis under the transgender umbrella was an important way to help a lot of people who now consider trans rights to not have much to do with them (because they don’t want to transition and identify with their birth sex) that it actually has a ton to do with them, because anyone who diverges from gender norms is a target of the same patriarchal system.
Again, no clue who this dude is, this is just one of my old trans recites memories at clouds routines. Caveat: I can only speak for my own memories of the time, someone else may be able to speak more accurately than me.
I wasn’t alive in the 90s and I wasn’t aware of trans stuff until I started exploring my gender in 2019 so as a result I am kinda ignorant of the way things were in the 00s and earlier. I really don’t see things like trans* and trans+ being used today, similarly to how you don’t really see people using antiquated terms for transgender either.
Today what I see instead is trans and GNC (gender nonconforming) which serves the same purpose of being a broad umbrella term but is more accurate.
As a computer nerd myself, the wildcard aspect makes me feel like trans* includes things like transportation and transghwujdjrudndndjjd which I don’t like.
Anyways, its not up to cishet person to decide what term should be used to refer to transgender and gnc people. I have a unfinished project, which is a website compiling a bunch of info and resources for trans and gnc people. I came across the genderbread at some point but I decided to research the creator before adding it to the site and that is how I discovered the above info about him.
I’d strongly suggest looking through places like the Queer Zine Archive Project and the Digital Transgender Archive if you’re working on a project like that. FWIW I don’t think he coined the term Trans* at all, and it’s just fallen out of favour now. When I first figured things out at 12 in the early 2000s, it was a term used online a lot. Especially as Transsexual and Transgender were (genuinely) considered slightly divergent things. These days only Truscum seem to believe that though and Transsexual has definitively fallen out of favour too.
Thanks for the suggestion! I know he didn’t coin the term but he did write an article on his website trying to get people to use it. He definitely did grab it from the past but either didn’t realize or didn’t care that it has fallen out of usage.
trans* is a C pointer
Dang, I guess the counselor who printed this had no idea. I’m no longer at that jobsite, but I’ll let the next person know if I see this again.
From my very basic cis position and trying to learn as much as possible of the right ways to name each, this graphic is actually quite nice, but it confuses me that things like hobbies, roles, jobs, personality traits are treated as part of gender identity… Is it just me and my autistic ass that considers those as completely independent from the gender identity? My gender identity is really clear to me, but I don’t let that define what hobbies I may have or like what movies I should watch or something like that.
That’s definitely one of the problems with this graphic. Those are a part of “gender roles”, stereotypical expectations of masculinity/femininity. Your impulse to consider them independent is correct, but you may encounter bigots with old fashioned ideas about what’s appropriate for someone to get up to based on their gender.
If I’m understanding you correctly, I think the key distinction is that gender expression is completely arbitrary and based on the society you’re in, but gender identity is something that is tied to your inner sense of self/brain and seems to develop fairly early in children (3-4).
For example, wearing a piece of clothing that has a single opening for both legs and stops at the knees would be called a skirt and be considered solely a feminine gender expression in most areas, but a kilt and something considered a masculine gender expression if it has the right pattern and is in Scotland. There’s no functional difference between them, it’s completely social.
That said, we do live in a society and all that, and people tend to want their gender expression to match (or at least complement) their gender identity. What you wear and do doesn’t change who you are, but who you are likely changes how you feel about what you wear and do.
deleted by creator
Overall, I agree. That said, because of the socially constructed associations with gender, people sometimes find euphoria from doing those things as a result and experiencing that euphoria (not because you enjoy the thing, but because its a “feminine”/“masculine” thing) could be a sign that perhaps you should consider that maybe your gender isn’t the one assigned at birth.
Good poster if not extremely simplistic, however I understand why thats the case.
Still complicated enough to melt the brains of bigots like they’re the Wicked Witch of the West
This is from a high school counselor’s office, maybe thats a factor
Sure but imo at least mentioning nonbinary people would be an improvement
Do you have a more detailed and accurate infographic? I’d love to have one.
Edit: I’ve seen the unicorn one here and searched around and found a few others on https://lgbtqia.fandom.com/wiki/Identity_diagrams
Though, I feel like years ago I saw one that had more dimensions and possibly had accounted for genderfluid people. Also, I don’t like that these all include sex assigned at birth, that seems shitty.
Bread is amazing and gender is cool
I wonder how genderbread tastes
“bread is amazing”
downvoted.
Bread is the best type of food