I have a banking app which sends confirmation codes for every action by SMS, and then for the final step for a transfer it sends a code via push notification to the app itself, which is auto-filled and submitted.
“Unique 4-digit verification code.” Low ambitions for the size of your userbase, huh?
This isn’t an indictment of their user base, this is very evidently a severe lack of security professionals. This might be the most sharp razor that Occam ever made lmao.
It can be both. If you have “unique 4 digit verification codes”, then you can’t have more than 10,000 users total.
I believe these are not permanent codes but only used once for verification. Not every user is logging in for the first time every day.
Honestly I find whatsapp even more insane, especially if that bullshit is the only auth method they might need
Hey yeah, thayd only be able have like four people. Ha idiots
“Security is a priority, but not a high one. Thats why we ignored best practices. But you’re stupid and we’re banking on you not realizing this.”
It’s a deliberate choice that filters out people who would be a pain in their ass by expecting them to actually work. Only the unthinking easy marks will go along with this, and are therefore simple to fleece.
You underestimate how much even IT people hate authentication because they don’t know how it works.
It is the bane of my existence, as the security person who has to guide these “professionals” on how to set it up.
TBF, security is about preventing things from happening, while most programmers got into the job to make things happen. It’s a very different mindset when thinking about how to approach what you’re trying to do.
Absolutely agreed, I am beyond blessed that my company’s dev team all have a bunch of security experience / certs, it’s extremely nice not having to worry about them doing dumb shit like this lmao.
“We send the code to enter direct to the device you’re holding so that anyone holding the device can get in!”
And we lead with the number so you can see it without unlocking the device!
Dude when you put it like that 😂 wtf
Yeah a lot of two-factor authentication is pointless these days because the second authentication is travelling unsecured to the same device you’re holding. Its a little different if there’s an authenticator app that needs some kind of verification to open and get the rotating key, but just texting you a code is pointless busy work if you’re accessing the site sending you the code from the device they are sending the code to.
I mean it’s not pointless pointless? The point is that you don’t want someone who isn’t you to be able to log in from anywhere else, by just entering your email or phone number, even if they know those pieces of information. They have to also have access to those things, giving the second factor. It’s not “totally secure”, but just a second factor or hurdle that they have to get over in order to gain access to what you have, right.
So if someone already has your phone or email compromised/in possession, then yeah, of course, that factor is totally rendered inoperative. 😁
Or would you say there’s something I’m missing here? 😅
Yeah okay that’s fair.
“Do you want us to show your four-digit PIN to Meta or Google?”
Did someone read something about passkeys being more secure than passwords and then just assume that they could roll their own passwordless solution and have it be just as secure?
Security may be a priority for them but they do not understand it enough to actually implement good security





