- cross-posted to:
- memes@sopuli.xyz
- cross-posted to:
- memes@sopuli.xyz
Crossposted from https://fedia.io/m/science_memes@mander.xyz/t/4559012
Maybe engineering was a mistake.
You know, that’s one thing I really hate is when all information provided in a lesson is surface level only.
“I’m just gonna tell you what this thing is. You don’t need to know the why or the how or the how we found any of this out.” - that’ll be $900 a credit hour. Thank you very much.
The advanced classes don’t make sense unless you already know the stuff you had to take on faith in the intro classes. Seeing the big picture requires having enough of its small pieces in your mind, and until you get to that point each small piece necessarily feels somewhat arbitrary.
Then you circle around to where you start answering kindergarten level questions like “What even is a number?” with way more detail and rigor than you thought possible.
“We’d love to tell you - but the slow kids need to pass, or I’ll lose my job.”
Most of the time, we can’t dig too deep because we’re paced at middle of a class. Other times, the derivation is beyond the student’s ability to follow without a lesson or two dedicated to it (and even then, what level are you building from - the axiomatic or some random midpoint system?).
Then you find out it’s all surface level and we don’t know what energy, or entropy, or gravity, or time, or space, or matter actually are nor how or why they work.
I… think we have fundamental answers for all of those? Einstein’s field equations and the subsequent research into particle physics and quantum mechanics which came from them have done a pretty stellar job in that regard. At this point the “big” unanswered questions are far more abstract than can be easily described, and we’re finding that questions like “what is space” are, as the late great terry prachett described, “the wrong sort of question”. It’s a very neat time in physics, although I confess I’m not much more than a physics cheerleader.
We can describe their behavior under normal circumstances and make predictions about it, but under extreme circumstances like very hot, cold, big, small, fast our understanding of the behavior reaches its limits. Then there’s the question of what they are. Energy and space are complete unknowns, gravity actually has a mechanical description from relativity but breaks down at the quantum level, time and entropy are essentially mysteries because we can not answer what exactly they are or why they only go in one direction, only that they do.
Why Mr. Gödel, what a pleasant surprise to see you’ve joined the fediverse…
I can already forsee that this is going to devolve to bickering about what it means to ‘answer a question’ remarkably quickly and, truly, neither of us need that. I hope you have a lovely morning!
This is why I hated school, especially math. All memorization, no why
You learn counting so that you can do addition and subtraction. You learn addition and subtraction so you can do multiplication and division. You learn multiplication and division so that you can do fractions and ratios. You learn fractions and ratios so that you can do algebra. You learn algebra so that you can do trigonometry. You learn trig so that you can do calculus. You learn calculus so that you can do differential equations.
There is a reason for it, but for some reason teachers don’t like explaining these things to you. Either that, or you’ve been told this before and it just didn’t click because it was said so subtly, it didn’t have any power behind it.
The elastic modulus of concrete is calculated as 57,000 times the square root of f’c, where f’c is the 28-day compressive strength of a concrete cylinder. (The force required to break the cylinder divided by the cross-sectional area.)
This formula, the 57,000sqrt(f’c), is a vitally important formulas. The elastic modulus is used to predict deflections of concrete elements and other calculations.
This equation also cannot be derived from first principles; it’s purely empirical. Engineers just made and busted a whole lot of concrete cylinders and beams and fit a curve to it.
This method has been used for basically every concrete building in the United States. Sleep well tonight.
Why would people not sleep well knowing that? Derivation from first principles is only as good as our representation of those first principles; no model perfectly represents its system and complex models especially so. This is why we do experiments in the first place, to confirm that we haven’t bungled the math. That concrete buildings are designed based on the result of exhaustive testing rather than an abstractly idealized vision of the world should be far more reassuring than the alternative.
Why would people not sleep well knowing that?
Because we don’t know why it’s true so we don’t know when it might be false. Doubly so for something like concrete which is a mixture whose proportions and ingredients can vary. Obviously most people in well-designed buildings are under little risk of having concrete pillars collapse on them, but generally it’s better for safety if we know how stuff works.
so we don’t know when it might be false
Why? An experimentally derived model is generally not the same as one derived from first principles true, but that has no impact on it’s applicability. For example, we know experimentally from within the set of controlled parameters when it is false and when the experimental model collapses, and as with a FP-derived model we can make make accurate extrapolations about other situations with known conditions from there.
(I’m sure I have better things to be doing with my time besides reading matsci papers from 1936, but this turns out to be a fascinating topic. Particularly, the use of the Elastic Moduli was known at the time to be a way of simplifying the actual behavior of concrete, which is (for a given value of “not”) not an elastic material. However it looks like as far back as [old enough they’re using Fortran] we have been able to derive an accurate model of concrete behaviors (and have been aware of how one could be created), but it took decades for computing power to progress to the point that we could test it, as it relies on the simultaneous physical interaction of ~30 different parameters across the time domain in what I’m blearily going to describe as an ‘ur-FEA’…)
(seriously it turns out aggregate modeling is a fascinating topic, can’t believe I’ve never found this one before)
This is why factor of safety is a thing. Bigger factor of safety = greater confidence it won’t break. Builders cheapening out on material costs worries me more.
My favorite is “calculating this is trivial so…” followed by skipping straight to the answer.
just do rocket science, its not brain surgery! xD
all the equations are very easy to conceptualize, after all, they’re all about how a rocket functions! :D







