• 0 Posts
  • 177 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: May 16th, 2025

help-circle

  • Every long human written math paper has cosmetic mistakes in it. I’ve even read a 9 page paper where they put a 3 where they should have put a 4. It didn’t matter at all for their result (they only needed it up to big O). I am not sure how many of these commenters understand the difference.

    I do not have remotely enough expertise or time to evaluate the human proof, but an ignorant person running AI on it and reporting mistakes does not really indicate anything substantial.

    Also, there are no 250,000 pages to verify because the prompter never released them. There is only the Lean proof (which the prompter certainly would have checked before releasing).





  • One of the major functions of AI is laundering responsibility. If someone makes a bad decision and AI was involved, they can blame the AI. More often these days, we also see the reverse. Overworked employees are forced to use AI while not having nearly enough time to review the slop. When something breaks, it couldn’t have been the AI’s fault. AI cannot fail, it can only be failed.

    Now I think AI development itself is another big example of laundering responsibility. AI was not inevitable, and all normal people know it. The residents protesting data center development know it, the students booing commencement speakers know it. AI development was only possible because of the whims of a few rich oligarchs who forced it upon everyone. It doesn’t even make money! Their rationalist courtiers act real smug and feel like their prophecies are coming true, all while trillions of dollars are going into the furnace to actively realize those prophecies.

    Their obsession with predictions and lines on charts really shows their belief that the future is something that happens to them, not something they make. They idolize people who get a ton of election bets right on Polymarket, but never in a million years would they get their asses off the couch and vote, let alone call phones and knock on doors.



  • I am sick and tired of all this benchmark business. It really feels like people staring at tea leaves and bird patterns and sheep guts to see if they line up with the prophecy written in the book some random shady oracle sold them 200 years ago. If they wanted a clear picture, why don’t they just ask a practitioner in the field? Ask a programmer if software has become very reliable and user-friendly, and if codebases are well-structured and easy to maintain and not spaghetti nightmares. Or they could just open their eyes and see Microsoft and the FAA shitting their pants on two consecutive days. But I guess it’s not Rational if it doesn’t let them make up 37 numbers.


  • The funniest part of Jensengate is seeing all the techbros being really sad and petitioning to restore Jensen to his rightful position, thinking that there is some analogy to Sam Altman. They seem to not realize that the reason Saltman was fired was because the board didn’t like his stupid face. Meanwhile, Jensen has committed three affairs, two with employees, and somehow that is the less important thing, considering he smuggled tens of billions of dollars of chips illegally into China. I wouldn’t be surprised if he ends up in jail. If Jensen thought he had a reasonable chance of surviving, why would he resign and start whining like a teenager?

    They even built a vibe coded petition website with zero user validation whatsoever:


  • Outlook was down for an entire day yesterday, which affected me since my school email uses it. I don’t remember any Outlook outage this bad before, and from what I’ve heard, Microsoft was cosplaying as a headless chicken in their attempts to fix it. Maybe getting rid of 60,000 employees to embrace the magic of AI isn’t working out so well.

    Meanwhile I saw this AI panic post on Linkedin (warning: psychic damage). Apparently all the doomers are vindicated and all the critics are completely discredited because of … you guessed it, math problems! You see, one mathematician was very sad in an interview! (Let’s also ignore the many nuanced statements like this that mathematicians have made about their own field.)

    But somehow he hasn’t noticed AI affecting anything he actually understands. Well, you see, that’s because in the real world, the magic of AI does need to wait a few years before the puny humans understand how to wield its power (but of course the doomsday is coming on schedule in a few years). The argument sounds nice until you look at of software, where there should be no physical obstacles for adopting AI. Now, coding has been solved by AI on the planet of Earth Prime where he lives, where OpenAI and Anthropic have long monopolized every software market with products of much higher quality and reliability than what came before. Unfortunately, I live on Earth, where I have seen two major vibe-coding failures in the last two days (the Outlook outage and the Humble Store rewrite).


  • Back of the envelope, this means the spontaneous generation of this organism is less likely than 1 in 4^50,000, or about 1 in 1e30000, to say nothing of the machinery required for actually transcribing the DNA and synthesizing proteins

    Are the Wrongers using their Powers of Rationality to literally rediscover creationist talking points?

    I remember during my first year of undergrad, I saw some dumbass creationist with a big poster in the middle of a courtyard. I was so dumbfounded that I decided to take a picture of the poster (I didn’t grow up around creationist types so I found it shocking). One of the talking points on that poster was that the probability that 18000 base pairs randomly happen to be correct is around 10^-10000. Quite funny that this Wronger offers even worse odds.









  • Vibe coded websites really are the epitome of AI: there’s tons of flashy stuff that looks impressive at first glance, but shit starts breaking down with the slightest breeze. The reading progress widget was working perfectly for me at first, but then I clicked around a bit (the “see what’s coming” link in that widget straight up leads to a 404) and then it got stuck at 88% for me. The slider in the “Timeline Explorer” is also extremely laggy for me, with an update taking 1-2 seconds. There’s also some UI elements that don’t make sense, like the four options in the bar above the “Countdown to AGI Achievement” box are duplicated in the “AGI scenarios” sidebar on the right side immediately below. Sometimes the drop down menus from the top just open randomly when I’m clicking something else. Also some buttons break occasionally and I need to refresh to fix them.

    Even though my own work does not involve any coding, I have seen a vibe coded project secondhand from someone who wanted to use it because they thought it would save time. It is very impressive at the start, since it can just pump out tons of features very quickly. But then disillusionment sets in as the project turns into a game of whack-a-mole where you yell at the AI to fix an issue and then two more pop up. And no way in hell are you fixing things yourself, because the codebase is an unreadable pile of spaghetti.