• 3 Posts
  • 635 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 22nd, 2024

help-circle




  • I think that a historical analysis explains the conflict pretty neatly. FOSS came into being among hippy-adjacent computer professionals and hobbyists at a time when those people were a much larger share of the people using computers. Even if you were just looking to dick around playing games on the family computer, simply doing that required a degree of relative technical sophistication. The culture was still more heavily impacted by the academic hackers of previous eras and it was assumed that using a computer with even a functional level of proficiency was always going to require a level of famiarity with how it works and what’s going on ‘under the hood’ that would allow and encourage users to write and customize their own software, and being prevented from doing so by corporate fiat was antithetical to the future of computers as a whole.

    Instead, as was arguably predictable, people wanted to take advantage of the power of digital computers without needing to establish and maintain a whole catalog of specialist knowledge and skills. The technology increasingly was designed to mold itself around the user rather than demanding the casual user meet it halfway. UI/UX design started taking a more central position compared to architecture and software design principles, and the increasing speed and availability of internet connectivity allowed for applications to be directly centralized through a client-server model. In the dark ages your terminal connected to a mainframe because the hardware and infrastructure required centralization. The internet re-centralized largely because users wanted to offload as much of the technical and mental workload away from themselves as they could. I think the FOSS true believers usually frame this as a corporate conspiracy against the user, but for the average user this wasn’t an abdication of power and skills - they didn’t have the skills or power in the first place, and didn’t want them. Instead they were allowed to continue focusing on their own shit without having to become computer people.

    This is what leads us to the current situation where the most organized and impactful group of people opposing the current oligarchic dynamic that increasingly dominates not just the domain of computing but the global economy as a whole are focused on a set of specialist concerns that are at best orthogonal to the problems most people have with the current system. Their proposed solutions are also directly opposed to the part of the current system that most other people actually find positive. That disconnect is very easily weaponized by the beneficiaries of the current ecosystem to minimize the degree to which the FOSS crowd can advance their goals and to minimize everyone else’s will to find and implement an alternative.

    I don’t have a solution here, but I fully agree that the four freedoms of FOSS are not adequate or even necessarily appropriate.


  • I think focusing on the economics and political processes also addresses my main criticism of the response to OS-Sci. While the libertarian emphasis on legalistic frameworks goes beyond the scope of this kind of ethical framework, pretending that the ethical framework alone is going to be meaningfully impactful without some kind of mechanism to enforce its precepts even against people who would choose to violate them is effectively surrender. Or to use the catchphrase: No, everyone will not “just”. Actively understanding why people choose to violate those ethical or community-focused duties and actively designing policies - including, where appropriate, democratically elected legal frameworks - to change the incentive structure and prevent defectors from profiting off of everyone else’s commitments is a necessary corollary of the ethical framework being advanced here.









  • You’re a damn fool, Dick! That’s not guilt weighing on your conscience, it’s an alien embryo eating its way through your heart!

    just like my ex-wives. I was surprised there was anything left to eat. But I was realizing I still had enough to hurt

    Stop monologuing, Dick! We have to get you to a doctor before it bursts through your manly trenchcoated chest!

    I wondered if I would be a better father than mine had been. Given I’d be dead I figured I had a head-start on the old bastard

    Oh, Dick…

    [Grayscale Splurtching Noises]






  • I would expect that the bigger problem is going to be the actual movement of chips. They’ll probably to keep the focus on the affair rather than actually interrogating the degree to which sanctions were violated. “Tech CEO is a dick to his family” hasn’t exactly ended the career of anyone else so long as the money keeps moving. But given how much the domestic AI push has used hawkishness about China to justify itself there could be real problems keeping congress at bay if it turns into both an anti-AI CEO issue and an anti-China issue.