• Rioting Pacifist@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    22
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    7 hours ago

    The entire AI industry is scams in scams

    NVIDIA is paying customers to buy their shit (and never deploy them)

    China’s humanoid robots are bought by local governments to sell training data back to the manufacturers.

    While the US leaning on protectionism is a sign off weakness, so is China’s use of “Frontier models” & US chips.

    I don’t think any credible analysis has China leading given their dependence on US tech, I also don’t think DeepSeek’s numbers are any more real than openAI so the idea that they are more efficient because they are cheaper is funny.

    what is probably true is China is close enough that with/without protectionism that US AI companies will not be making profits big enough to justify their IPOs about time soon.

    • Nola@piefed.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      18
      arrow-down
      4
      ·
      6 hours ago

      I think this fundamentally misses some important context though.

      China’s goal is not to try and out compete on having the most advanced proprietary model so they can put enclosures around their tech and charge rents. Then prop up the profits of a handful of companies with elaborate circular funding schemes and gatekeeping protectionism.

      China envisions AI as a open weight, widely distributable, customizable, general-purpose technology that can be integrated throughout its entire economy(and the rest of the world). The goal is to diffuse the technology as broadly as possible, drive down the cost of adoption, and build an entire industrial ecosystem around it.

      And that is not the whole strategy but one component.

      China’s top priority in their recent 5 year plan is not to develop the most advanced frontier model, it’s to dramatically improve and scale up the production of computer components like advanced RAM, GPU’s, and the broad hardware supply chain for AI.

      Anyone that has ever messed with local LLM’s knows how intensive that is.

      So on the one end you have people like Altman saying they want to take ram and gpus out of consumer’s hands, put up massive protectionism, and regulate access so they can be the feudal lords over their proprietary tech and extract rents.

      On the other side is China chasing a strategy of making AI models cheaper, more accessible, and more customizable, while simultaneously investing in the domestic industrial capacity to manufacture the hardware needed to run them.

      To me China is making the wiser, more holistic, and long term sustainable bet.

      • NathanRanch@lemmy.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        4 hours ago

        How does China plan to make good on this hardware? I get the notion, but it’s divorced from reality as the AI bros. Your argument rings like, China’s black hole of investment isn’t as deep as the American black hole. China could pull out of the AI boom and win by default, yet we see them trying to get into the swamp for some reason.

        • Nola@piefed.zip
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          7
          ·
          3 hours ago

          I don’t see it as a similar black hole

          US AI investment last year was roughly $290 billion. China’s was $12 billion. That’s a 23 to 1 ratio. And yet the actual output is nearly identical based on Stanford HAI’s 2026 AI Index

          Presumably people will need ram, motherboards, GPU’s, CPU’s, and rare earth metals even when this bubble pops, no?

          AI still does have utility as we see in China with it’s incorporation into things like their factories, driverless infrastructure, academic research, military spending, and probably most important for China: assissting with their more centrally planned economy. Which all gives them a tangible competitive edge and helps grow other businesses as well.

          In Shenzhen, I toured Huawei Technologies’ assembly line for its newest Mate 90 smartphones. Zha Jun, who oversees Huawei’s research and development, explained that this line used to have 86 workers per shift — doing mostly manual inspections — and the rest of the work force was robots. It recently shrank that to nine people by turning to A.I.-enabled image recognition systems.

          When I asked what kind of data center it used to run the A.I. systems, Zha said: “We have no need for a data center. Huawei can get all the A.I. benefits it needs for these kinds of manufacturing improvements using our own open-weight, domain-specific A.I. models with less than one billion parameters.” Those are the ones with circuitry that amounts to the size of a small suitcase. (Parameters are a measure of the connections and weights that an A.I. model uses to process information and are used as a general proxy for its complexity and capacity to learn.) These small A.I. models, Zha added, were “good enough” to make big improvements in manufacturing.

          American AI companies are trying to put enclosures around knowledge itself and charge everyone rent for access, fostering a codependency and then profiting off being it’s gatekeeper(and increasingly root themselves into government functions to extract lucrative one sided deals). This was the classic Uber/Amazon strategy of trying to debt finance your way into market monopoly to create a techno fiefdom you then have immense control over not just your direct business, but others as well. Which also means they either need to cartelize or it incentivizes a race to be the best frontier model and become the dominant player while doing this circular financing game. All for a product they can’t find profitability from as they envision and is far more problematic as a replacement for white collar work then they envisioned(now one off ramp would also be a controlled bubble demolition and bail out, which I wouldn’t rule out happening and seemingly many investors are investing based on that assumption).

          Look at China in literally every other domain they have come to dominate. They build the foundation. Focus on establishing vertically integrated supply chains, build domestic manufacturing capacity usually centering critical components. Form an entire industrial ecosystem around that domain. Then they leverage industrial policy, public financing, economies of scale, and competition to drive down costs and diffuse that technology throughout the economy and then export it abroad.

    • peopleproblems@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      14
      ·
      7 hours ago

      “Listen carefully, Feyd,” the Baron said. “Observe the plans within plans within plans.”

      My special interest in Dune is getting out of hand at this point.